Additionally, he ultimately encourages his audience to view Lewis learning as evidence against the common notion of the unproductivity of the mentally ill, as we see Lewis development flourish during his time at the asylum. The prompt is phrased as an instruction (Compare) which invites you to analyse both texts together, but you totally knew that already! Well be applying the CONVERGENT and DIVERGENT strategy from LSGs How To Write A Killer Comparative and at how ideas are developed in similar or different thematic directions in these texts. Should children be allowed to roam unsupervised by their parents. Whilst Skrzynecki mainly describes the immigrant experience in his poems, we can also find an overarching warning to not take loved one, and their knowledge for granted, as often we dont have them for as long as we would hope. She pushes him to make a choice between the world of insanity and fidelity that represents truth for Lewis, or the world of sanity, free love and politics that Lewis comes to view as restrictive and stifling. SAC:A sustained oral piece (~4-6 minutes) that presents a point of view relating to an issue currently in the media + a written explanation (~300-500 words) explainingyour decisions made in the planning process, and how these demonstrate your efforts in attempting to persuade the audience. And in answer to your questions, whilst its best you analyse the whole collection to some extent, knowing 10 or so strategically chosen poems really well, covering all themes and types should hold you in good stead for any question thrown at you in the exam. This type of prompt also grants you some freedoms that other types dont give. Skrzynecki often uses places of transit such as train stations or hostels to showcase the uncertainty often experienced in a migrants journey. Skrzynecki often reminisces about his childhood and uses it as a way to explore both his experience in his new world of Australia, and his old world of his Polish roots. Better Essays. Since women are like that the interpretation of Cos fan tutte, Mozart supported the belief that men should simply accept that women will inevitably be disloyal in relationships. Yes, they know what they're doing, and so should you. What I have spoke: but farewell compliment! The LSG's THINK and EXECUTE technique follows three steps in the THINK phase - Analyse, Brainstorm, and Create a Plan. What you should aim to do:If your school hasn't made the decision for you already, it's crucial that you choose a topic that is original and offers you room for argument. Although we see the theatre being touched up with new lights and a coat of paint, it still remains derelict and run-down. In contrast, the following shot of Lisa in the positive foreshadows the development of the film, as he begins to perceive Lisa as a possible life partner: Want to save this for later? All of the action takes place inside a burnt-out, derelict theatre. not just Lewis changing values)., It is not only Lewis who develops in Cos, but other characters as well.. The VCAA provides the only official, up to date versions of VCAA publications and information about courses including the VCE. Here are some lines from Juliet's monologue and an explanation in modern English. If youd like the full picture on our best FREE advice on Text Response, check out our Ultimate Guide to VCE Text Response here. If you're curious to learn more, have a look through some of our posts onOral Presentationideas for inspiration! These prompts are pretty easy to spot if you see a characters name in the prompt, there you have it; you have a character-based prompt on your hands. Now is the sun upon the highmost hill. Linking Sentence(s): In contrasting Lewis meekness to his boldness, Nowra alludes to the personal benefits that personal growth can have. However, these institutions are upheld in different ways, and require different mechanisms of changewhile the play emphasises grieving and unity, the novel focuses more on emancipation. However, Nowra also uses the theatre as a symbol of hope. Planning is an essential part of any successful text response essay. As the poems detail an immigrants emotional journey, alternating between feeling that they belong and dont belong, we are invited to grapple with what it means to belong both mentally and physically as well as what elements are required to feel a sense of belonging in community and country. Much like Lewis protective delusion, Roy uses illusions of a happy childhood to shield him from facing his reality. englewood section 8 housing. Her guilt bubbles to the surface here because its as though shes the villain here, and shes to blame for leaving him alone. The play is sort of built around the five stages of grief but demonstrates how First Nations grief isnt neat or linear. does climate change exist?). Aposporos delivers the show's most effective dramatic scene, a moving monologue. Nowra suggests that love is complex and cannot be fully understood or tamed, instead portraying it as akin to madness. The key here is to look at the bigger picture what are the major values and messages that the texts deliver? Secondly, interpret the themes and issues addressed in the quote and implement these into your discussion. God, these endless extended moments where youre left in limbo, the time dangling like a suspended toy on a piece of elastic.. These poems also demonstrate the experiences of relief and joy felt when arriving, as well as emotions of fear, trepidation and disconnect in regards to both their new home and their old world. Theres a self-projection of anxiety here with Liz assuming that the childcarers are unable to look after Daniel properly, and that hes suffering. Weve explored historical context, themes, essay planning and essay topics over on our Like a House on Fire by Cate Kennedy blog post. Lastly, it's vital to remember that Cos is a play, not a book, and on top of that, it is a play within a play. Abandoned him to a roomful of rampaging strangers. Should pick-up artist Julien Blanc have been banned from visiting Australia? Whilst many students may struggle with this form and ask How many poems do I analyse? Its rarity is likened to the absence of womens fidelity, yet never male fidelity. Of this day's journey, and from nine till twelve. However, customs are also seen to be the way in which migrants make themselves at home whilst being able to still identify with their past. Within the frame of the main window, the windows of each apartment act as mini frames within the big frame, multiplying the sense of voyeurism present in the shot. Reconciliation needs to include Aboriginal voices. On top of that,you will need to focus on your delivery of the speech, which includes things like tone, pace, eye-contact, and much more! Languages ability to also expose the differences between people and make them feel like outsiders is also explored in First day of school and The Polish Immigrant as people such as teachers struggle with the pronunciation of Polish names and inevitably have to ask boy, how do you pronounce that?. Meanwhile, Don Alfonso manipulates everyone. Therefore, Nowra shows that communication and truthfulness are needed for healthy, and reciprocal, relationships. In regard to this Macbeth prompt, for example, you could explore the different ways the theme of ambition is presented in the text. However, Shakespeares Macbeth adoptsvery different methods as he uses violence and abuse to secure his power. At the start of the play, Lewis allows himself to be influenced by Lucys values rather than his own, but by the end, Lewis true views prove to be very different from hers.. Even her sense of smell betrays her being away from Daniel. 4. O, he is the courageous captain of compliments. 3. VCE is a registered trademark of the VCAA. One of the most central themes of Skrzyneckis poems is that of belonging. This links to Nowras view of the senselessness of war, which he views as a problem that mankind has created for themselves. However, as they are only the Joneses of his own minds making it also showcases his commitment to not simply copy and to still be individual. At first, Lewis shares the same values as his friends Nick and Lucy - that love is not so important in the days of politics and war. This close shot of a destroyed, seemingly irreparable camera, literally reflects the cyclic nature of broken dreams characteristic of Greenwich Village, and also signifies that Jeff too has been hurt (literally) by radical pursuits in his progression. "Cosi julie" Essays and Research Papers. Give yourself one minute. For that which thou hast heard me speak to-night. Sort By: Satisfactory Essays. As love is universal, this view ties in nicely with his non-judgmental perspective on madness and insanity. Are they the opposite? By identifying the type of prompt youre being challenged with immediately, a number of parameters or guidelines are already set in place. 3. The only things adorning Jeffs small room are his many photographs, all taken by himself. At the beginning of the play, Lewis states that his grandmother was in an asylum. 7. The protagonist of Cos, Lewis is a new university graduate who has agreed to direct a play cast with patients from a mental institution because he needs money. The medias portrayal of terrorism. Its depicted as a home invasion, a ship taking up a whole harbour, and as a process of devaluing land and ignoring its custodians. Because weve got two sets of ideas for each text, lets alternate the texts (Essay Structure 1, as discussed in How To Write A Killer Comparative) to cover these ideas in four paragraphs. In doing so, he critisises traditional perspectives of sanity and insanity and instead encourages his audiences to consider the complexity of madness., The question of what is real or an illusion is weaved through the patients state of mentality. Ambition in the play Macbeth leads to success. Discuss. The author of this text, as well as a character in his own right, Peter describes his triumphs and struggles of immigrating to Australia in his poems. Watch my video on quick presentation tips which helped me score full marks in my SAC! Within the THINK strategy, we have 3 steps, or ABC. Roy explains the plot, as firebug Doug (David Wenham) jeers at the concept. This desperation is viewed in another light during Julie and Lewis kiss (which takes place in the dark). [2] The play was adapted into the 1996 film Cosi .